Crate Training Vs Playpen: Which Is Right For Your Dog?
This is our comparison of dog crate training Vs playpen.
I am a dog parent and walker who has researched, as well as used, both dog crates and playpens to help you determine which option is best for your pooch.
Dog Crate And Playpen Comparison
Dog crates and playpens do not serve the same function. One is not used instead of the other. They are used to complement each other.
For example, a dog crate is a safe space for your pooch and is preferred for potty training as a pup is unlikely to go to the bathroom where they sleep.
A playpen, on the other hand, is for playing. It allows dogs to move around safely in a confined area while you are getting things done around your house.
A playpen is not great for potty training as it is big enough so that your pooch can potty in one corner and play in the other.
A dog crate is more appropriate for training purposes and providing a safe space for your pooch whereas a dog playpen is more suitable for allowing more freedom and playtime when you’re around to supervise.
Let’s get started with an in-depth look at what sets crates and playpens apart.
Potty Training
An appropriate-sized dog crate is recommended for potty training your dog. Because it is a small space, your pup is less likely to soil where they sleep.
A playpen, however, is big enough for your pooch to relieve themselves in one corner and play in another.
Winner: Dog Crate
Emotional Support
Your dog should have a safe space to get away from noise and irritations (kids!) and a crate is a perfect place for them to chill out.
Make it comfy for your pooch with a dog bed, and it’s a great place for them to retreat to for some quiet time and naps.
A pen, on the other hand, is large and is generally associated with play. It’s a place where you and your family can hang out with your pooch safely and have a good ol’ time.
A playpen is too big to function as a quiet, safe space for your pup.
Winner: Dog Crate
Length Of Time
Dog crates are ideal if your pooch is going to be alone for several hours at a time.
The age of your pup should determine the amount of time they are alone in their crate.
An older dog is able to stay in their crate longer than a puppy who has a small bladder.
Dog playpens are not intended for your dog to be left alone in for hours on end.
It is meant to be a fun area for your dog to hang out in and safer than roaming around your house freely.
Winner: Dog Crate
General Guidelines For Crate And Playpen Training Your Dog
The best way to teach your dog to stay in a crate or pen is to start as early as possible.
Practice daily in small time increments.
Don’t start off with 5 hours a day, that’s guaranteed to backfire and slow down any progress.
Instead, start with very short increments of time and gradually work your way up to longer durations.
Crate and pen training when your pooch is tuckered out, such as after a walk or outdoor training session will likely yield more positive results.
A tired pup is more likely to settle in than one that has a ton of energy and wants to go, go, go.
Positive reinforcement with treats is a great idea too.
You can purchase (or make) training treats that are small and won’t upset your pup’s food schedule when rewarded frequently.
Verdict
Dog crate training is the overall winner of the epic battle of crate training vs playpen.
But, there are advantages to using both dog crates and playpens.
Crates are ideal for potty training and provide a safe space for your pooch to sleep and relax in.
Playpens are handy when you’re at home and need to get things done without your pooch getting underfoot.
You might find that both a crate and a playpen are useful for your pup.
A place to play and a place to chill safely. It’s a win-win for both of you!
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
Where Should I Set Up A Puppy Playpen?
Anywhere in your home where you feel it is safe for your pup to be left.
A room with a tile floor is great as it allows for easier ‘mess’ cleanup. Your living room might be a good place also as it’s a general hang-out spot for you and your family.
Your pooch will want to be close to you and a playpen is a great, mobile way to keep your pup safe an feel included in the fun.
Do I Need A Playpen If I Have A Crate?
Depends. A crate is great for potty training and providing a safe place for your pup to relax and sleep.
A playpen functions as a place for your pooch to play and have fun. It is not great for potty training because they can pee in one corner and play in the other.
Where Is The Best Place To Put A Crate?
During the day, your pooch should be near the action. A busy area such as a living room or kitchen is ideal.
At night, a quiet place such as your bedroom is ideal where they can chill out and get to sleep comfortably.
What Is A Good Alternative To A Playpen?
You could tether your dog to you using a leash during the day when you’re puttering around the house.
This way they can safely join you on your adventures.
If your pooch is going to be alone, a crate is a great option as well.
What Size Pen Should I Get For My Dog?
The size of your pen is determined by the size of your home.
Decide which room(s) you are going to use the playpen and purchase one that fits there.
There are a ton of different options for pens, so it should be fairly easy to find one appropriate for your particular space.
When Should I Stop Using A Pen?
This is highly dependent on your pup. Generally, when your pooch is house-trained and trustworthy, you can stop using a playpen.
When Should I Stop Using A Crate
This is entirely up to you.
You can choose to get rid of the crate once your dog is potty trained and trustworthy or keep it up forever and use it as a safe space for your dog to retreat to and sleep in whenever they want.
Kathy Burley
Author
Kathy enjoys hiking with her dog, Ollie, and the rest of her dog walking pack. As well as researching and creating articles to help you make informed decisions that are BEST for your dog.
Save 35% on your next dog food order!
We have partnered with Chewy.com to offer the best deal on high-quality dog food to our readers. If you click on the button below, we will take you to their exclusive discount page.
0 Comments